Romeo and Juliet Grade 9 Model Answer

Here is a full model essay written by our examiners, followed by notes on what lifts it into the top band. Use it to see what precise language analysis, purposeful context and links across the whole play look like, then practise the same skills in your own words.

The question

This is an extract-based question in the style of AQA Paper 1. Read the Prologue, which is spoken by the Chorus at the very start of the play.

CHORUS
Two households, both alike in dignity
(In fair Verona, where we lay our scene),
From ancient grudge break to new mutiny,
Where civil blood makes civil hands unclean.
From forth the fatal loins of these two foes
A pair of star-crossed lovers take their life;
Whose misadventured piteous overthrows
Doth with their death bury their parents’ strife.
The fearful passage of their death-marked love
And the continuance of their parents’ rage,
Which, but their children’s end, naught could remove,
Is now the two hours’ traffic of our stage;
The which, if you with patient ears attend,
What here shall miss, our toil shall strive to mend.

Starting with this extract, explore how Shakespeare presents ideas about fate in Romeo and Juliet. Write about how Shakespeare presents fate in this extract and how Shakespeare presents fate in the play as a whole.

Model answer

Shakespeare presents fate in Romeo and Juliet as something far less distant than the stars. The Prologue appears to tell us that the lovers are doomed by the heavens, yet almost every image of destiny in it is rooted in the family, the city and the feud. Writing in the mid 1590s for an audience who largely accepted that the stars could influence human lives, and adapting Arthur Brooke’s 1562 poem, which had presented the story as a warning to disobedient children, Shakespeare uses the language of fate to shift the blame. By telling us the ending before the play has begun, he changes the audience’s question from “what will happen?” to “why must it happen?”, and the answer he offers is the hatred of the parents’ generation.

The form of the Prologue is itself a statement about fate. It is a Shakespearean sonnet, fourteen lines of iambic pentameter ending in a rhyming couplet, the form that Elizabethan poets in the 1590s used above all for love. Shakespeare takes the form of romantic love and fills it with “death”, “rage” and “strife”, so that before the lovers have even met, their story is locked inside a fixed pattern of rhyme and metre. The sonnet’s strict structure works like destiny: the ending, the couplet, is determined by the shape of everything that comes before it.

The opening quatrain establishes the feud before it mentions the lovers at all. The phrase “both alike in dignity” uses the noun “dignity” to mean rank, but its sense of self-respect makes the feud sound absurd, since the families are equals with nothing to prove. The antithesis between “ancient grudge” and “new mutiny” shows that the past keeps erupting into the present, as if the hatred has a life of its own. The repetition of “civil” in “civil blood makes civil hands unclean” is especially pointed. The first “civil” means belonging to the citizens, but the second hints at “civilised”, exposing the contradiction of a polite society whose hands are stained with the blood of its own people. The adjective “unclean” carries a religious charge of sin, which prepares for the ending, where heaven will punish Verona.

In the second quatrain, Shakespeare places the origin of the tragedy in the parents’ bodies. The noun phrase “fatal loins” is a powerful pun: “fatal” means both fated and deadly, and “loins” are the parts of the body that produce children. The lovers are born from their parents’ feud, and the same adjective that suggests destiny suggests death. In the next line, the compound adjective “star-crossed” presents the lovers as thwarted by the stars, but the verb phrase “take their life” is deliberately ambiguous. It means that they are born, yet it also means that they will kill themselves, so birth and suicide are collapsed into a single line. Shakespeare suggests that their deaths are written into their beginnings. Even their reward is grimly ironic: “Doth with their death bury their parents’ strife.” The verb “bury” belongs to the funeral, and the heavy alliteration of “Doth” and “death” gives the line a solemn, falling rhythm. Peace comes, but only at the graveside.

The third quatrain turns fate into a journey. In “The fearful passage of their death-marked love”, the noun “passage” suggests both a voyage and the passing of time, while the compound adjective “death-marked” implies that their love is marked out for death, branded like an animal for slaughter. Crucially, the clause “Which, but their children’s end, naught could remove” interrupts the sentence, trapping the “children’s end” in the middle of the line just as the children are trapped between their parents. The noun “end” means death, but it can also mean purpose, suggesting the bleak idea that the lovers exist to end the feud. Finally, the metatheatrical phrase “the two hours’ traffic of our stage” reminds the audience that the play is a performance. In one sense, the playwright himself is the fate controlling these lives, and the closing couplet’s appeal for “patient ears” quietly invites us to judge what we see.

Throughout the play, Shakespeare keeps this sense of doom alive through foreshadowing. On his way to the Capulet feast, Romeo fears that “my mind misgives / Some consequence yet hanging in the stars / Shall bitterly begin his fearful date / With this night’s revels”. The present participle “hanging” makes fate feel suspended over him like a sword, and the adjective “fearful” echoes “The fearful passage” of the Prologue. Yet Romeo goes in anyway, handing control to “he that hath the steerage of my course”. The nautical metaphor recalls the “passage” of the Prologue, but it also shows Romeo surrendering responsibility, a pattern that will cost him dearly. When Juliet discovers who he is, her exclamation “My only love sprung from my only hate!” repeats the structure of the Prologue’s “fatal loins”: once again, love grows directly out of hatred.

Act 3 Scene 1 is the turning point, and here Shakespeare tests the idea of fate most sharply. Before the fight, Benvolio warns that “now, these hot days, is the mad blood stirring”, making violence seem a product of heat and temper rather than the stars. After killing Tybalt, Romeo cries “O, I am Fortune’s fool!” The noun “fool” presents him as a plaything of fate, but the audience has just watched him choose to fight. Earlier in the scene he even recognises that “This day’s black fate on more days doth depend.” The adjective “black” suggests mourning and evil, yet the line is about consequences: one violent act will produce others. Shakespeare allows the characters to call it fate, while the structure of the scene shows it is the feud. Mercutio’s dying curse, “A plague o’ both your houses!”, is grimly fulfilled when the Friar’s letter fails to reach Romeo, because Friar John, who carries it, is sealed in a house suspected of plague. For an audience who had lived through the plague that closed London’s theatres for much of 1592 to 1594, this detail would have felt horribly real, and it turns a curse born of the feud into the instrument of chance.

The lovers themselves sense the ending. As Romeo leaves for Mantua, Juliet cries “O God, I have an ill-divining soul!” and sees him “As one dead in the bottom of a tomb.” The compound adjective “ill-divining” suggests a prophetic gift that brings only bad news, and the downward movement of “so low” and “the bottom of a tomb” pulls their last farewell towards the vault of Act 5. In the tomb, Romeo resolves to “shake the yoke of inauspicious stars / From this world-wearied flesh!” The metaphor of the “yoke” presents fate as a burden laid on an ox, and the adjective “inauspicious” returns to the astrology of the Prologue. Tragically, his attempt to defy the stars is exactly what fulfils the Prologue’s prophecy that the lovers will “take their life”.

The ending completes the frame. Friar Lawrence claims that “A greater power than we can contradict / Hath thwarted our intents”, but his words sound like an excuse from a man whose rushed plans have failed, especially since he once warned “Wisely and slow. They stumble that run fast.” The Prince offers a different reading: “See what a scourge is laid upon your hate, / That heaven finds means to kill your joys with love”. The noun “scourge”, a whip used for punishment, presents the deaths as divine judgement on the parents, not on the lovers, and the antithesis of “hate” and “love” mirrors the Prologue’s structure. His blunt statement “All are punished” spreads guilt across the whole city. Finally, his closing couplet, “For never was a story of more woe / Than this of Juliet and her Romeo”, rhymes like the end of a sonnet, so the play closes as it opened, enclosed within poetry.

Ultimately, Shakespeare uses the language of fate to make his audience look harder at human choices. The stars may be “inauspicious”, but the Prologue’s most important images, the “fatal loins”, the “parents’ strife” and the “parents’ rage”, all point back to the older generation. Unlike Brooke, who blamed the young lovers, Shakespeare suggests that fate is the name people give to the consequences of their own hatred, and that a society which passes its feuds on to its children should not be surprised when it ends up burying them.

Why this answer reaches the top band

What it doesExamples from the essay
A conceptualised argument (AO1). The essay opens with a clear, debatable idea: fate in the play is rooted in the family feud, not just in the stars. Every paragraph returns to it.The opening and closing paragraphs frame the whole essay around the same idea, and the final sentence turns it into a message about the older generation.
Fine-grained language analysis (AO2). It names precise word classes and techniques and explains their effect: the pun on “fatal loins”, the ambiguous verb phrase “take their life”, the compound adjective “death-marked”, the noun “scourge”.Look at how each quotation is broken down into individual words and sounds, such as the alliteration of “Doth” and “death”.
Structure as well as language (AO2). It comments on the sonnet form, the quatrains, the interrupting clause about the “children’s end” and the closing couplets that frame the play.The paragraph on form and the final paragraph on how the play ends as it began.
Insightful context tied to purpose (AO3). Context explains why Shakespeare writes as he does: Elizabethan belief in astrology, Brooke’s moralising source, the 1590s fashion for sonnets and the plague that closed the theatres.Each piece of context arrives straight after the analysis it explains, never as a separate history lesson.
Writer’s intentions throughout. It keeps asking why Shakespeare tells the ending first and what he wants his audience to judge.The introduction’s point about changing “what” into “why” and the conclusion’s contrast with Brooke.
Links across the play. It traces images from the Prologue through the whole play: the “fearful passage” and Romeo’s “fearful date”, the “fatal loins” and “My only love sprung from my only hate!”, the “plague” curse and the lost letter, the stars in the Prologue and Act 5.Phrases such as “echoes”, “recalls” and “completes the frame” signal the links.

FROM QUALIFIED TEACHERS AND EXAMINERS

Revise the whole of Romeo and Juliet with us

Our Romeo and Juliet course takes you scene by scene, character by character, with video lessons, model answers and lessons on writing top-grade essays. Start with a free account, or unlock every course for under £7 a month with Annual Access.

See the Romeo and Juliet course →Join for free

FROM QUALIFIED TEACHERS AND EXAMINERS

Ready to go further?

The full Romeo and Juliet course

Video lessons, model answers and lessons on writing top-grade essays, all created by qualified teachers and examiners.

See the course

BEST VALUE FOR YEAR 11

Y11 Season Pass

Every GCSE and IGCSE English course for one payment of £59.99. Access until 30 June 2027, through mocks and every exam. Nothing to cancel.

Get the Season Pass