Frankenstein Grade 9 Model Answer

Here is a full model essay written by our examiners, followed by notes on what lifts it into the top band. Use it to see what precise language analysis, purposeful context and links across the whole novel look like, then practise the same skills in your own words.

The question

This is an AQA-style extract question. The extract comes from Chapter 5 of the 1831 edition, moments after Victor has brought the creature to life.

Starting with this extract, how does Shelley present Victor’s response to the creature he has made?

Write about: how Shelley presents Victor’s response in this extract; how Shelley presents Victor’s response to the creature in the novel as a whole. [30 marks]

The different accidents of life are not so changeable as the feelings of human nature. I had worked hard for nearly two years, for the sole purpose of infusing life into an inanimate body. For this I had deprived myself of rest and health. I had desired it with an ardour that far exceeded moderation; but now that I had finished, the beauty of the dream vanished, and breathless horror and disgust filled my heart. Unable to endure the aspect of the being I had created, I rushed out of the room, and continued a long time traversing my bedchamber, unable to compose my mind to sleep. At length lassitude succeeded to the tumult I had before endured; and I threw myself on the bed in my clothes, endeavouring to seek a few moments of forgetfulness. But it was in vain: I slept, indeed, but I was disturbed by the wildest dreams. I thought I saw Elizabeth, in the bloom of health, walking in the streets of Ingolstadt. Delighted and surprised, I embraced her; but as I imprinted the first kiss on her lips, they became livid with the hue of death; her features appeared to change, and I thought that I held the corpse of my dead mother in my arms; a shroud enveloped her form, and I saw the grave-worms crawling in the folds of the flannel.

Model answer

In this extract Shelley presents Victor’s horror at his creature as something far stranger than disgust at an ugly face: it is the moment when a man who longed to be a god discovers that he does not want the responsibility of being a parent. The creature has done nothing except open its eye and breathe, yet Victor has already condemned it. Shelley wrote the novel in 1816 and 1817, as a teenager who had lost her first baby and whose own mother had died within days of her birth, and she presents Victor’s flight from his creation as the novel’s original sin. Everything that follows traces its consequences. Her real question is not whether science can create life, but whether those who create will care for what they make.

The extract opens with a generalisation: “The different accidents of life are not so changeable as the feelings of human nature.” The abstract nouns “accidents” and “feelings” lift Victor’s narration above the event, as if he were a detached philosopher rather than the man responsible. Yet the comparative structure “not so changeable as” quietly admits his own instability, and the noun “accidents” is ironic in a chapter where nothing has been accidental: Victor chose every step. The next sentences show how deliberate it was. The time phrase “for nearly two years” and the noun phrase “the sole purpose” present an obsession, while “infusing life into an inanimate body” uses the cool, Latinate vocabulary of the laboratory. The verb “deprived” in “I had deprived myself of rest and health” shows that Victor has already harmed himself, an early hint that ambition consumes the ambitious first.

The turning point arrives in a single sentence balanced on a semicolon: “I had desired it with an ardour that far exceeded moderation; but now that I had finished, the beauty of the dream vanished, and breathless horror and disgust filled my heart.” The noun “ardour” belongs to the language of romantic love, so creation becomes a kind of passion, and the admission that it “far exceeded moderation” is the closest Victor comes to accepting blame. The conjunction “but” then swings the sentence from desire to revulsion. The noun “dream” is crucial: what Victor loved was never the creature but his fantasy of it. The adjective “breathless” is grimly ironic, since in the paragraph before, the creature has only just “breathed hard” into life; as his creation gains breath, the creator loses his. The paired abstract nouns “horror and disgust” are both physical and moral, and the verb “filled” suggests that there is no room left in Victor’s heart for anything else, including pity.

Victor’s response is not to examine what he has made but to flee from it: “Unable to endure the aspect of the being I had created, I rushed out of the room”. The noun “aspect”, meaning appearance, shows Victor judging purely by the surface, the same prejudice that every human will later show the creature. The relative clause “I had created” insists on his ownership even as he runs from it, and the urgent verb “rushed” gives way to the aimless “traversing” of his bedchamber, as if he has nowhere real to go. Shortly afterwards, when the creature comes to his bedside, Shelley makes the abandonment almost unbearable: “one hand was stretched out, seemingly to detain me, but I escaped, and rushed down stairs.” The outstretched hand is the gesture of a baby reaching for a parent, and the adverb “seemingly” shows Victor refusing to read it generously. The verb “escaped” casts the newborn as a captor and Victor as the victim, a self-pity that runs through his whole narrative.

The dream reveals what Victor will not admit while awake. He sees Elizabeth “in the bloom of health”, but “as I imprinted the first kiss on her lips, they became livid with the hue of death”. The semicolons build the nightmare as a chain of transformations, each clause darker than the last, until “I saw the grave-worms crawling in the folds of the flannel.” The natural image of “bloom” decays into the Gothic detail of “grave-worms”, and the soft alliteration of “folds of the flannel” makes the horror disturbingly intimate. Shelley fuses Victor’s future bride with his dead mother, whose death from scarlet fever in Chapter 3 came just before he left for Ingolstadt, so the dream hints that his science was an attempt to conquer death and to create life without a woman at all. It is also a prophecy. In Chapter 23 Victor will embrace Elizabeth “with ardour”, the same noun used for his ambition in this extract, only to find that “what I now held in my arms had ceased to be the Elizabeth whom I had loved and cherished.” The repetition shows that Victor’s abandonment of the creature leads directly to the death of the woman he loves.

The recoil in Chapter 5 is all the more shocking because of the ambition that came before it. In Chapter 2 Victor says “It was the secrets of heaven and earth that I desired to learn”, and in Chapter 4 he imagines that “A new species would bless me as its creator and source”. The verb “bless” places Victor in the position of God, and the pronoun “me” shows that he dreams of gratitude, not of the care he will owe. The novel’s subtitle, The Modern Prometheus, recalls the Titan punished for stealing fire from the gods, and in her 1831 introduction Shelley imagined “the pale student of unhallowed arts kneeling beside the thing he had put together.” The adjective “unhallowed” and the dismissive noun “thing” anticipate Victor’s own language: just before the extract, he calls his creation “the lifeless thing that lay at my feet”. Shelley’s first readers knew of experiments such as Giovanni Aldini’s in 1803, when electric current made the face of an executed criminal twitch and an eye open, so the “dull yellow eye” of the creature opening at the start of Chapter 5 would have felt disturbingly close to real science.

When the creature finally speaks, Shelley lets the abandoned child judge its parent. In Chapter 10 he tells Victor “I ought to be thy Adam; but I am rather the fallen angel”. The modal verb “ought” turns a relationship into a moral duty that Victor has failed, and the allusion to Milton’s Paradise Lost contrasts God’s care for Adam with Victor’s neglect. In Chapter 15 he cries “Accursed creator! Why did you form a monster so hideous that even you turned from me in disgust?” The intensifier “even”, together with the italics Shelley gives to “you”, makes Victor’s rejection the cruellest of all because it came first. The creature’s claim that “misery made me a fiend” reflects the belief of Shelley’s father, William Godwin, that character is formed by circumstances, so Victor’s response in this extract becomes the cause of every murder that follows.

Victor never truly learns. In Chapter 20, facing the half-finished female creature, he “tore to pieces the thing on which I was engaged.” The noun “thing” repeats the dehumanising language of the extract, and the violent verb phrase “tore to pieces” repeats his rejection on a second being. His guilt is real but self-absorbed. After Justine’s execution he declares “I, not in deed, but in effect, was the true murderer.” The antithesis of “deed” and “effect” shows him understanding responsibility in words while refusing it in action, because he tells no one the truth. Even as he dies, he advises Walton to “Seek happiness in tranquillity, and avoid ambition”, blaming ambition rather than his own coldness towards what he made.

Shelley ends the novel not with Victor but with the creature, grieving over his creator’s body and then “borne away by the waves, and lost in darkness and distance.” The alliteration of “darkness and distance” closes the novel on a being who has been pushed away from the moment he first reached out a hand. In the Chapter 5 extract, Shelley shows the exact moment Victor makes that choice. Her message, written in an age of dazzling scientific discovery by a writer who knew loss and abandonment first-hand, is that creation brings responsibility, and that the real monstrosity of Frankenstein lies not in a face but in a failure to love.

Why this answer reaches the top band

What it doesExamples from the essay
A conceptualised argument (AO1). The essay opens with a clear, debatable idea: Victor’s horror is a refusal of parental responsibility, and his flight is the novel’s original sin. Every paragraph returns to it.The opening and closing paragraphs frame the whole essay around the same idea.
Fine-grained language analysis (AO2). It names precise word classes and techniques and explains their effect: the abstract noun “accidents”, the romantic noun “ardour”, the ironic adjective “breathless”, the adverb “seemingly”, the modal verb “ought”.Look at how each quotation is broken down into individual words, not just explained as a whole.
Structure as well as language (AO2). It comments on sentence structure (the sentence balanced on a semicolon, the chain of semicolons in the dream) and on the novel’s shape, including the creature’s narrative at its centre and the ending.The paragraphs on the turning point, the dream and the ending.
Insightful context tied to purpose (AO3). Context explains why Shelley writes as she does: her own losses, Prometheus, Aldini’s experiments, Paradise Lost and Godwin’s ideas about circumstances.Each piece of context arrives straight after the analysis it explains, never as a separate history lesson.
Writer’s intentions throughout. It keeps asking what Shelley wants her readers to see, and ends on her message about the responsibility of creators.The introduction, the paragraph on the creature’s voice and the conclusion.
Links across the novel. It connects moments: “ardour” in Chapter 5 and Chapter 23, the outstretched hand and the final image of the creature, the “thing” in the introduction, Chapter 5 and Chapter 20.Phrases such as “It is also a prophecy” and “repeats the dehumanising language” signal the links.

FROM QUALIFIED TEACHERS AND EXAMINERS

Revise the whole of Frankenstein with us

Our Frankenstein course takes you chapter by chapter, character by character, with video lessons, model answers and lessons on writing top-grade essays. Start with a free account, or unlock every course for under £7 a month with Annual Access.

See the Frankenstein course →Join for free

FROM QUALIFIED TEACHERS AND EXAMINERS

Ready to go further?

The full Frankenstein course

Video lessons, model answers and lessons on writing top-grade essays, all created by qualified teachers and examiners.

See the course

BEST VALUE FOR YEAR 11

Y11 Season Pass

Every GCSE and IGCSE English course for one payment of AED 291.00. Access until 30 June 2027, through mocks and every exam. Nothing to cancel.

Get the Season Pass