Animal Farm Grade 9 Model Answer

Here is a full model essay written by our examiners, followed by notes on what lifts it into the top band. Use it to see what precise language analysis, purposeful context and links across the whole novel look like, then practise the same skills in your own words.

The question

How does Orwell present Napoleon as a corrupt leader in Animal Farm?

Model answer

Orwell presents Napoleon less as a pig who is corrupted by power than as a pig whose hunger for power is present from the start, waiting only for the revolution to hand him the means. Orwell wrote the novella in 1943 and 1944, while Britain was allied with Stalin’s Soviet Union, and several publishers turned it down. In “Why I Write” (1946) he described Animal Farm as the first book in which he tried “to fuse political purpose and artistic purpose into one whole”, and Napoleon is where that fusion is sharpest. The simple surface of a fable allows Orwell to expose, with almost childlike clarity, how a revolution built on equality hardens into a dictatorship, and how much that dictatorship depends on the silence of those it rules.

Napoleon’s very first description reads like a charge sheet. He is “a large, rather fierce-looking Berkshire boar, the only Berkshire on the farm, not much of a talker, but with a reputation for getting his own way.” The sentence is built from a list of clauses, so each detail lands as a separate piece of evidence. The adverb “rather” offers a polite, very English understatement, yet it cannot soften the compound adjective “fierce-looking”, which places menace in his appearance before he has done anything at all. The phrase “the only Berkshire on the farm” isolates him from the herd before Animalism even exists, and the conjunction “but” turns his silence from a weakness into a threat: he does not need words when he has a “reputation”. The possessive “own” in “getting his own way” sets individual will against the collective “we” of Old Major’s dream. Even his name works as a prophecy. Napoleon Bonaparte rose through the French Revolution and then crowned himself Emperor in 1804, so Orwell’s choice of name signals from the start that this revolutionary will end as a monarch. Like Stalin, who was a weaker speaker than Trotsky but a master of committees and quiet manoeuvring, Napoleon gains power through what he controls rather than what he says.

Orwell shows that this corruption begins almost at once, and that it is hidden inside ordinary language. After the rebellion, the narrator reports that “The mystery of where the milk went to was soon cleared up. It was mixed every day into the pigs’ mash.” The casual idiom “cleared up” treats a betrayal as a puzzle solved, mimicking the way the animals shrug it off. The passive voice of “was mixed” removes the agent entirely: no pig is named as responsible, which mirrors how privilege under a dictatorship arrives through quiet routine rather than open theft. The time phrase “every day” turns a single act into a system. Orwell, who fought in the Spanish Civil War and watched Soviet-backed communists turn on their own left-wing allies in 1937, understood that a revolution can be betrayed long before anyone notices, and the flat, two-sentence structure here makes the reader notice what the animals do not.

Napoleon’s true source of power is revealed in Chapter 5, when he expels Snowball. Instead of answering Snowball’s speech, Napoleon “uttered a high-pitched whimper of a kind no one had ever heard him utter before.” The noun “whimper” is pointedly non-verbal: debate, the tool of Snowball and of democracy, is defeated by a pre-arranged animal signal. At once “nine enormous dogs wearing brass-studded collars came bounding into the barn.” The metallic, militaristic detail of “brass-studded collars” suggests uniformed guards, while the collar itself is a symbol of being owned, so the dogs are both weapons and possessions. Orwell then reveals that “they were the puppies whom Napoleon had taken away from their mothers and reared privately.” This links back to Chapter 3, where Napoleon promised to “make himself responsible for their education”. In hindsight, “education” becomes a euphemism for indoctrination, and the adverb “privately” quietly contradicts the shared ownership that Animalism promised. The dogs represent Stalin’s secret police, and Snowball’s exile echoes Trotsky’s expulsion from the Soviet Union in 1929. Most tellingly, Orwell notes that “they wagged their tails to him in the same way as the other dogs had been used to do to Mr. Jones.” The comparison “in the same way as” places Napoleon and Jones side by side halfway through the novel, preparing the reader for the moment at the end when pig and man become indistinguishable.

Napoleon’s corruption also depends on rewriting the past. When he adopts the windmill he once opposed, Squealer explains it away by repeating “Tactics, comrades, tactics!” while “skipping round and whisking his tail with a merry laugh.” The abstract noun “tactics” sounds intelligent but explains nothing, and its repetition with exclamation marks replaces reasoning with rhythm. The playful verbs “skipping” and “whisking” make the lie feel harmless, which is exactly what makes it dangerous. Historically, this mirrors Stalin taking up the rapid industrialisation that Trotsky had argued for once Trotsky had been removed. It also anticipates Orwell’s lifelong concern with how political language can hide the truth, which he went on to explore in “Politics and the English Language” (1946) and Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949).

The executions in Chapter 7 are where Napoleon’s corruption becomes murderous. After the animals confess, “the dogs promptly tore their throats out, and in a terrible voice Napoleon demanded whether any other animal had anything to confess.” The adverb “promptly” has the efficiency of an office memo, and the coordinating conjunction “and” joins the killing and Napoleon’s next question in a single breath, as if slaughter were simply an item on the agenda. The pig who was “not much of a talker” now speaks in “a terrible voice”. The next sentence is structured to bury the reader: “And so the tale of confessions and executions went on, until there was a pile of corpses lying before Napoleon’s feet and the air was heavy with the smell of blood, which had been unknown there since the expulsion of Jones.” The noun “tale” recalls the subtitle “A Fairy Story”, making the horror more chilling for being told in a storybook register. The image of corpses “lying before Napoleon’s feet” turns the dead into offerings laid before an idol, and the final clause explicitly links Napoleon to Jones once again. Orwell is alluding to Stalin’s show trials of 1936 to 1938, in which defendants confessed to crimes they could not have committed. Afterwards, “The animals huddled about Clover, not speaking.” The verb “huddled” reduces the revolutionaries to frightened livestock, and the participle phrase “not speaking” shows that terror has achieved what argument never could. Their song “Beasts of England” is then abolished because “It’s no longer needed, comrade”, which echoes the Soviet Union replacing “The Internationale” as its national anthem in 1944, while Orwell was writing.

Napoleon also corrupts the law itself. After the killings, the Sixth Commandment is found to read “No animal shall kill any other animal without cause.” Just two words have been added, yet they reverse its meaning, because Napoleon alone decides what counts as a “cause”. Orwell shows that a corrupt leader does not need to break the rules if he can quietly rewrite them, and that a population which cannot read or remember clearly cannot defend its own rights. The same corruption reaches Napoleon’s image. In Chapter 8 he is “always referred to in formal style as ‘our Leader, Comrade Napoleon,'” and the pigs like to invent for him “such titles as Father of All Animals, Terror of Mankind, Protector of the Sheep-fold, Ducklings’ Friend, and the like.” The capital letters build a grand, quasi-religious list, which then collapses into bathos with “Ducklings’ Friend”, and the dismissive “and the like” suggests that the titles are endless and empty. Orwell is mocking the cult of personality that surrounded Stalin, in which flattery became compulsory. The possessive “our” in “our Leader” is especially sinister, as it claims to speak for the very animals Napoleon is oppressing.

By the final chapter, the prophecy in Napoleon’s name has come true. After a baying of dogs and a crowing cockerel, “out came Napoleon himself, majestically upright, casting haughty glances from side to side, and with his dogs gambolling round him. He carried a whip in his trotter.” The adverb “majestically” belongs to the language of royalty, completing the journey from revolutionary to emperor, while “upright” breaks the founding maxim “Four legs good, two legs bad.” The playful verb “gambolling” sits grotesquely beside dogs we have watched tear out throats. Orwell then delivers a short, blunt sentence: “He carried a whip in his trotter.” The whip was once the symbol of Jones’s cruelty, so its return shows that the oppressor has changed species but not behaviour, and the humble noun “trotter” deflates all the grandeur of “majestically”. In the closing line, “The creatures outside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which.” The circular structure of the sentence, turning back on itself, mirrors the circular structure of the novel, which ends almost where it began. The scene of pigs and men at the card table is often read as a reference to the Tehran Conference of 1943, where the Allied leaders met with Stalin, and it reflects Orwell’s anger that the West was so ready to treat a dictator as a respectable partner.

Ultimately, Orwell presents Napoleon as the logical result of unchecked power rather than an accident of history. As a democratic socialist, Orwell was not attacking the dream of equality that Old Major describes; he was attacking those who exploit that dream. Yet his warning reaches beyond Napoleon himself. Napoleon succeeds because Boxer adopts the maxim “Napoleon is always right”, because Squealer’s language goes unchallenged, and because the animals cannot remember clearly what was promised. In a fable deliberately simple enough for anyone to read, Orwell’s message is that tyranny depends as much on the silence of the governed as on the cruelty of the leader.

Why this answer reaches the top band

What it doesExamples from the essay
A conceptualised argument (AO1). The essay opens with a clear, debatable idea: Napoleon was never good, and his power depends on the silence of the animals. Every paragraph returns to it.The opening and closing paragraphs frame the whole essay around the same idea.
Fine-grained language analysis (AO2). It names precise word classes and techniques and explains their effect: the compound adjective “fierce-looking”, the passive voice of “was mixed”, the adverb “promptly”, the bathos of “Ducklings’ Friend”.Look at how each quotation is broken down into individual words, not just explained as a whole.
Structure as well as language (AO2). It comments on sentence structure (the list of clauses, the short blunt sentence about the whip) and on the circular shape of the whole novel.The paragraphs on Napoleon’s introduction, the executions and the ending.
Insightful context tied to purpose (AO3). Context is used to explain why Orwell writes as he does: the name Bonaparte, the Spanish Civil War, Trotsky’s expulsion, the show trials, “The Internationale” and the Tehran Conference.Each piece of context arrives straight after the analysis it explains, never as a separate history lesson.
Writer’s intentions throughout. It keeps asking what Orwell wants his 1940s readers to see, and ends on his message about the responsibility of ordinary people.“Why I Write” in the introduction and the final paragraph.
Links across the novel. It connects moments: the puppies’ “education” in Chapter 3 with the dogs in Chapter 5, the dogs wagging their tails as they did for Jones, and the whip returning at the end.Phrases such as “This links back to” and “once again” signal the links.

FROM QUALIFIED TEACHERS AND EXAMINERS

Revise the whole of Animal Farm with us

Our Animal Farm course takes you chapter by chapter, character by character, with video lessons, model answers and lessons on writing top-grade essays. Start with a free account, or unlock every course for under £7 a month with Annual Access.

See the Animal Farm course →Join for free

FROM QUALIFIED TEACHERS AND EXAMINERS

Ready to go further?

The full Animal Farm course

Video lessons, model answers and lessons on writing top-grade essays, all created by qualified teachers and examiners.

See the course

BEST VALUE FOR YEAR 11

Y11 Season Pass

Every GCSE and IGCSE English course for one payment of £59.99. Access until 30 June 2027, through mocks and every exam. Nothing to cancel.

Get the Season Pass