An Inspector Calls Grade 9 Model Answer

Here is a full model essay written by our examiners, followed by notes on what lifts it into the top band. Use it to see what precise language analysis, purposeful context and links across the whole play look like, then practise the same skills in your own words.

The question

How does Priestley present ideas about responsibility in An Inspector Calls?

Write about: what different characters think about responsibility; how Priestley presents ideas about responsibility by the ways he writes.

This is a whole-play question in the style of AQA Paper 2, where no extract is printed, so the essay draws on quotations from across all three acts.

Model answer

Priestley presents responsibility not as a private virtue but as a debt that every member of society owes to every other, and he builds the whole play as a trial in which the audience, as well as the Birlings, sits in the dock. Writing in 1945, when Britain was choosing between a return to pre-war individualism and the new welfare state, he sets the play in 1912 so that his audience can watch, with the hindsight of two world wars, what happens when a society refuses to accept that responsibility. The characters divide according to whether they can learn this lesson, and the play’s final twist suggests that no one, on stage or in the theatre, can escape it.

Priestley first gives the opposing view to Mr Birling, and he makes sure it is discredited before it is even finished. Birling announces that “I speak as a hard-headed business man”, and the compound adjective “hard-headed” suggests practicality but also a skull too thick for new ideas to enter. His authority is immediately undermined by dramatic irony when he declares that the Titanic is “unsinkable, absolutely unsinkable”. The repetition, intensified by the adverb “absolutely”, is the language of total certainty, yet the audience knew that the ship sank on her maiden voyage in April 1912, shortly after the evening in which the play is set. Having made Birling a false prophet, Priestley lets him state his creed: “a man has to mind his own business and look after himself and his own”. The polysyndeton of “and … and” piles up obligations, but every one of them turns inward, and the repeated possessive “his own” shrinks the circle of responsibility to a single household. The noun “business” is a pointed pun, meaning both private affairs and commerce, as though for Birling the two are the same. He sneers at those who imagine people living “like bees in a hive”, but the simile backfires: a hive is a model of cooperation, so his insult accidentally describes the society Priestley wants. Tellingly, it is at the climax of this speech that the doorbell rings. The structure of the play interrupts Birling just as his argument reaches its height, as if history itself is knocking at the door.

The Inspector’s entrance marks a shift from comfort to judgement. The stage directions call for the lighting to move from “pink and intimate” to “brighter and harder”. The soft adjectives of the opening suggest a rose-tinted, private world, while the comparatives “brighter” and “harder” suggest an interrogation lamp that leaves nothing in shadow. The Inspector himself creates an impression of “massiveness, solidity” and “purposefulness”; these abstract nouns, built with the suffix “-ness”, make him seem less a man than a principle. His method dramatises his message. He describes Eva’s death as the result of “a chain of events”, and the play’s episodic structure, in which each character is questioned in turn, forges that chain in front of the audience. Priestley borrows the form of the detective thriller, but subverts it: instead of one guilty person, the answer to “who did it?” turns out to be everyone.

Sheila is the first to grasp what this means. When her father defends sacking Eva, she replies “But these girls aren’t cheap labour”, and then “they’re people.” The contrast is between an economic noun phrase, “cheap labour”, which reduces workers to a cost, and the plain, human noun “people”, which restores their individuality. The conjunction “But” signals that she is now arguing against her father, joining Eric in a widening crack in the family’s united front. When she recognises her own part in Eva’s story, she vows “I’ll never, never do it again to anybody”. The repetition of “never” shows the strength of her shame, but the most important word is the indefinite pronoun “anybody”, which widens her responsibility from one girl to everyone. Priestley presents her as a model for his audience: someone who travels from private guilt to social conscience. Her journey is all the more striking because the stage directions introduce her as “very pleased with life”, a young woman whose comfort depended on not seeing people like Eva.

Mrs Birling, by contrast, represents the refusal to accept responsibility at all. Introduced as “a rather cold woman and her husband’s social superior”, she is defined from the start by temperature and rank, and the adjective “cold” anticipates her lack of charity in a woman who sits on a charity committee. Her phrase “Girls of that class” uses the demonstrative “that” to push Eva into a separate category of person, and her sneer “As if a girl of that sort would ever refuse money!” reveals that she cannot imagine moral principle in a working-class woman. Priestley then turns her own words against her. She insists that Eva “had only herself to blame” and orders, “Go and look for the father of the child. It’s his responsibility.” The imperative “Go” shows her habit of command, but the dramatic irony is crushing: the audience realises, before she does, that the father is her own son. She uses exactly the right noun, “responsibility”, but places it on someone else, and the curtain of Act 2 falls as Eric enters to confront her. Through Mrs Birling, Priestley attacks the pre-war idea of charity as a favour granted only to the deserving poor, the attitude that the Beveridge Report of 1942 and the welfare state set out to replace.

The Inspector’s final speech gathers these ideas into Priestley’s clearest statement of purpose. “We don’t live alone. We are members of one body. We are responsible for each other.” The three short declarative sentences build like a creed, and the shift to the first-person plural “We” pulls the audience into the statement. The metaphor of “one body” echoes St Paul’s image of the church as a single body with many members, giving socialism the moral weight of scripture: if one part suffers, all suffer. He reminds them of “millions and millions of Eva Smiths and John Smiths”, and the repetition of “millions” creates a number too large to count, while the commonest English surname turns Eva into an everywoman, joined by her male equivalent. Finally, he warns that “If men will not learn that lesson, then they will be taught it in fire and blood and anguish.” The conditional “If” frames this as a choice, and the polysyndeton slows the list so that each noun lands separately. To an audience in 1945, who had lived through the trenches and the Blitz, this was not a prophecy but a memory, and Priestley asks them not to make the same mistake a third time.

After the Inspector leaves, Priestley tests whether the lesson has been learnt by removing the threat of punishment. Once the Inspector seems to be a hoax, Mr Birling mocks “the famous younger generation who know it all”, and the sarcastic adjective “famous” shows that his only regret was the fear of a “public scandal”. Gerald, relieved, announces “Everything’s all right now, Sheila.” and asks “What about this ring?”, treating the engagement ring as if the evening could simply be undone. Sheila’s reply, “I must think”, is a short sentence built on a verb of reflection, showing that for her responsibility does not depend on being caught. Eric agrees that “the fact remains that I did what I did”; the repetition of “did” gives his guilt a blunt, stubborn weight that no telephone call can remove. Sheila tells her parents “you don’t seem to have learnt anything”, and it is the young, not the old, who now speak for the Inspector.

Priestley’s final structural twist ensures that the audience cannot dismiss the play either. The telephone rings to announce that a girl has just died and that an inspector is on his way, so the play’s cyclical structure threatens to begin all over again. Responsibility, Priestley suggests, is not a lesson taught once but a test that keeps returning until it is passed. Writing as Britain voted for a fairer society in 1945, he leaves his audience with the same choice as the Birlings: to say, like Gerald, that “Everything’s all right now”, or to accept, like Sheila and Eric, that we are all responsible for each other.

Why this answer reaches the top band

What it doesExamples from the essay
A conceptualised argument (AO1). The essay opens with a clear, debatable idea: responsibility is a shared social debt, and the play is a trial in which the audience is also in the dock. Every paragraph returns to it.The opening and closing paragraphs frame the whole essay around the same idea of a test that the characters, and the audience, must pass.
Fine-grained language analysis (AO2). It names precise word classes and techniques and explains their effect: the compound adjective “hard-headed”, the repeated possessive “his own”, the indefinite pronoun “anybody”, the demonstrative “that”, the first-person plural “We”.Look at how each quotation is broken down into individual words, not just explained as a whole.
Structure as well as language (AO2). It comments on the doorbell interrupting Birling’s speech, the lighting change, the episodic chain of interrogations, the curtain at the end of Act 2 and the cyclical ending.The paragraphs on Mr Birling, the Inspector’s entrance, Mrs Birling and the final twist.
Insightful context tied to purpose (AO3). Context explains why Priestley writes as he does: the 1912 setting and the Titanic, the two world wars, the Beveridge Report and the welfare state, the 1945 election.Each piece of context arrives straight after the analysis it explains, never as a separate history lesson.
Writer’s intentions throughout. It keeps asking what Priestley wants his 1945 audience to see and do, and ends on the choice he leaves them.The introduction, the paragraph on the final speech and the conclusion.
Links across the play. It connects moments across all three acts: Birling’s “his own” against the Inspector’s “We”, Sheila’s growth from “very pleased with life” to “I must think”, and Gerald’s “Everything’s all right now” echoed in the conclusion.Phrases such as “by contrast”, “Priestley then turns her own words against her” and “After the Inspector leaves” signal the links.

FROM QUALIFIED TEACHERS AND EXAMINERS

Revise the whole of An Inspector Calls with us

Our An Inspector Calls course takes you act by act, character by character, with video lessons, model answers and lessons on writing top-grade essays. Start with a free account, or unlock every course for under £7 a month with Annual Access.

See the An Inspector Calls course →Join for free

FROM QUALIFIED TEACHERS AND EXAMINERS

Ready to go further?

The full An Inspector Calls course

Video lessons, model answers and lessons on writing top-grade essays, all created by qualified teachers and examiners.

See the course

BEST VALUE FOR YEAR 11

Y11 Season Pass

Every GCSE and IGCSE English course for one payment of AED 291.00. Access until 30 June 2027, through mocks and every exam. Nothing to cancel.

Get the Season Pass