Here is a full model essay written by our examiners, followed by notes on what lifts it into the top band. Use it to see what precise language analysis, purposeful context and links across the whole novella look like, then practise the same skills in your own words.
The question
This is an AQA-style extract question. Read the extract from Stave One, then answer the question below it.
Oh! But he was a tight-fisted hand at the grind-stone, Scrooge! a squeezing, wrenching, grasping, scraping, clutching, covetous, old sinner! Hard and sharp as flint, from which no steel had ever struck out generous fire; secret, and self-contained, and solitary as an oyster. The cold within him froze his old features, nipped his pointed nose, shrivelled his cheek, stiffened his gait; made his eyes red, his thin lips blue; and spoke out shrewdly in his grating voice. A frosty rime was on his head, and on his eyebrows, and his wiry chin. He carried his own low temperature always about with him; he iced his office in the dog-days; and didn’t thaw it one degree at Christmas.
Starting with this extract, explore how Dickens presents Scrooge as cold and isolated, and how he changes, in A Christmas Carol.
Write about: how Dickens presents Scrooge in this extract; how Dickens presents Scrooge in the novel as a whole. [30 marks]
Model answer
Dickens presents Scrooge’s coldness not as a fixed part of his nature but as a winter he has made for himself and carries everywhere, and this is precisely what makes his thaw possible. Writing in 1843, after reading a government report on child labour, Dickens wanted to strike at the conscience of comfortable middle-class readers. In his preface he describes the novella as a “Ghostly little book” designed to raise “the Ghost of an Idea”, and Scrooge is the vehicle for that idea: if the most frozen man in London can be warmed, then so can any reader, and so can society.
The extract opens with the interjection “Oh!”, which gives the narrator the voice of a storyteller performing aloud, inviting the reader to share his mock outrage. The idiom “tight-fisted hand at the grind-stone” makes Scrooge’s meanness physical, a clenched fist pressing others down to sharpen his profit. This is then intensified by an asyndetic list of present participles, “squeezing, wrenching, grasping, scraping, clutching”, every one a verb of the hands. Their relentless “-ing” endings suggest that the grasping never stops, while the harsh consonants of “grasping, scraping” make the sentence itself sound abrasive. The list ends not with a verb but with the noun “sinner”, which shifts the reader from economics to morality: for Dickens, greed is not simply a bad business habit but a sin against other people. The exclamation mark makes the judgement emphatic, and the word “old” hints that this sin has had years to harden.
The two similes that follow are more complex than they first appear. Scrooge is “Hard and sharp as flint”, yet flint is the very stone used to strike a spark. Dickens’s qualification, “from which no steel had ever struck out generous fire”, places the problem not in the flint but in the fact that nothing has struck it yet. The adverb “ever” implies a lifetime of missed chances, and the adjective “generous” ties warmth directly to giving. In this way the simile quietly predicts the plot: the Spirits will be the steel. Similarly, the polysyndeton of “secret, and self-contained, and solitary as an oyster” slows the sentence down, and the hissing sibilance makes Scrooge sound closed and cold. An oyster is sealed in its shell, but it may also hold a pearl. Dickens suggests that something valuable is shut away inside this man.
Dickens then turns the weather inward. In “The cold within him froze his old features”, the cold is the grammatical subject and Scrooge’s body is its object, followed by a run of active verbs, “froze”, “nipped”, “shrivelled”, “stiffened”. Scrooge seems to be acted upon by his own nature, almost as if he were its victim. The possessive in “He carried his own low temperature always about with him” is crucial: the cold is his “own”, self-generated rather than imposed. The hyperbole that he “iced his office in the dog-days”, the hottest days of summer, is comic, but the final clause, “didn’t thaw it one degree at Christmas”, introduces the key metaphor of the whole novella. A “thaw” is exactly what will happen to Scrooge, and Dickens plants the word here so that the reader is waiting for it.
Across Stave One, this coldness becomes a moral blindness to the poor. When the charity collectors ask for help, Scrooge replies “Are there no prisons?” and declares that if the poor would rather die “they had better do it, and decrease the surplus population.” The abstract noun phrase “surplus population” echoes Thomas Malthus, whose theories were used to justify the harsh workhouses of the 1834 Poor Law. Dickens puts the language of economists into the mouth of a villain so that his readers hear how cruel it sounds. Even Scrooge’s thrift is chilling: “Darkness is cheap, and Scrooge liked it.” The short sentence, balanced around the conjunction “and”, links money and darkness so closely that his meanness becomes a kind of spiritual blindness.
Dickens then reveals how this isolation began, and this is where he invites sympathy. In Stave Two, the Ghost of Christmas Past shows Scrooge “A solitary child, neglected by his friends”. The adjective “solitary” deliberately echoes the “oyster” of Stave One, suggesting that the adult’s shell grew around a lonely boy. Dickens, who had been sent to work in a blacking factory at twelve while his father was in a debtors’ prison, knew how childhood neglect can harden into fear of poverty. When Belle tells the young Scrooge “Another idol has displaced me”, and names it as “A golden one”, the religious noun “idol” connects back to “sinner”: Scrooge has made money into a false god, and paid for it with love. By the end of Stave Two, Scrooge’s anguished cry, “I cannot bear it!”, shows that the shell is beginning to crack.
The thaw continues in Stave Three, where Dickens forces Scrooge to see the poor as individuals. Scrooge asks the Ghost to “tell me if Tiny Tim will live”, and the narrator notes that he speaks “with an interest he had never felt before”. The Ghost replies by quoting Scrooge’s own words: “If he be like to die, he had better do it, and decrease the surplus population.” The repetition is a structural masterstroke. The abstract statistic of Stave One is now attached to a specific, loving, disabled child, and Scrooge, and the reader, must hear the phrase again with shame. The same Ghost reveals Ignorance and Want, two children described as “Yellow, meagre, ragged, scowling, wolfish”, and warns “beware this boy”. Dickens widens Scrooge’s personal story into a warning to the whole of Victorian society.
By Stave Four, Scrooge’s language has changed completely. At his own neglected grave, he pleads “I am not the man I was.” and vows “I will honour Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year.” The modal verb “will” turns regret into a promise, and the phrase “all the year” redefines Christmas as a way of living rather than a date. In Stave Five, the man who carried his “own low temperature” is “as light as a feather”, “as happy as an angel” and “as merry as a schoolboy”. These similes reverse the extract: the weight of the chain gives way to lightness, coldness to happiness, and the old sinner to a schoolboy, as if Scrooge has been given back the childhood that was taken from him. Most strikingly, “His own heart laughed”. The same possessive “own” that described his self-made cold now describes self-made warmth, showing that the capacity to change was inside him all along.
Ultimately, Dickens presents Scrooge’s coldness as a choice, and therefore as something that can be unchosen. The flint was always capable of fire; it only needed striking. Scrooge raises Bob’s salary, becomes “a second father” to Tiny Tim and, in the narrator’s words, “as good a friend, as good a master, and as good a man, as the good old city knew”. The tricolon and the repetition of “good” restore Scrooge to every role he once rejected. Dickens’s message to his 1843 readers is clear and urgent: the wealthy are not born cold, they make themselves so, and if Scrooge can thaw, then so can they.
Why this answer reaches the top band
| What it does | Examples from the essay |
|---|---|
| A conceptualised argument (AO1). The essay opens with a clear, debatable idea: Scrooge’s coldness is self-made, which is why it can be undone. Every paragraph returns to it. | The opening and closing paragraphs frame the whole essay around the image of a thaw. |
| Fine-grained language analysis (AO2). It names precise word classes and techniques and explains their effect: the asyndetic list of present participles, the noun “sinner”, the adverb “ever”, the possessive “own”, the modal verb “will”. | Look at how the extract is broken down into individual words and sounds, such as the sibilance of “secret, and self-contained, and solitary”. |
| Structure as well as language (AO2). It comments on grammatical structure (cold as the subject of the sentence) and on the novella’s structure, especially the repetition of “surplus population” in Stave Three. | The paragraphs on “The cold within him” and on the Ghost of Christmas Present. |
| Insightful context tied to purpose (AO3). Context explains why Dickens writes as he does: the 1843 report on child labour, Malthus and the 1834 Poor Law, and Dickens’s own childhood in the blacking factory. | Each piece of context arrives straight after the analysis it explains, never as a separate history lesson. |
| Writer’s intentions throughout. It keeps asking what Dickens wants his middle-class readers to see and feel, and ends on his message to them. | The “Ghost of an Idea” in the introduction and the final paragraph. |
| Links across the novella. It connects the extract to every Stave: “solitary as an oyster” with “A solitary child”, “sinner” with “idol”, “his own low temperature” with “His own heart laughed”. | Phrases such as “deliberately echoes”, “connects back to” and “reverse the extract” signal the links. |
FROM QUALIFIED TEACHERS AND EXAMINERS
Revise the whole of A Christmas Carol with us
Our A Christmas Carol course takes you stave by stave, character by character, with video lessons, model answers and lessons on writing top-grade essays. Start with a free account, or unlock every course for under £7 a month with Annual Access.
FROM QUALIFIED TEACHERS AND EXAMINERS
Ready to go further?

The full A Christmas Carol course
Video lessons, model answers and lessons on writing top-grade essays, all created by qualified teachers and examiners.
See the courseBEST VALUE FOR YEAR 11
Y11 Season Pass
Every GCSE and IGCSE English course for one payment of AED 291.00. Access until 30 June 2027, through mocks and every exam. Nothing to cancel.
Get the Season Pass